Review Criteria

 
For Reviewers

Evaluation Criteria

These guidelines support fair, constructive, and rigorous peer review aligned with our mission and standards of excellence.

1. Originality & Contribution

  • Does the manuscript offer new insights, data, or interpretations?
  • Does it contribute meaningfully to global music studies?

2. Relevance to Scope

  • Is the topic aligned with our focus on music across cultures?
  • Does it engage with cross-cultural or interdisciplinary issues?

3. Theoretical Rigor

  • Is the research question clearly articulated?
  • Are theoretical frameworks appropriate?
  • Are methods sound, transparent, and justified?

4. Structure & Clarity

  • Is the manuscript well-organized with logical flow?
  • Are arguments clearly supported by evidence?
  • Is the language precise for an academic audience?

5. Engagement with Scholarship

  • Does it critically engage relevant literature?
  • Does it situate itself within ongoing scholarly conversations?

6. Use of Sources & Media

  • Are sources appropriately used and cited?
  • Are musical examples or media materials effectively integrated?

7. Ethical Considerations

  • Are ethical standards upheld (consent, citation, permissions)?
  • Are any conflicts of interest disclosed?

8. Final Recommendation

Accept
Minor Revisions
Major Revisions
Reject