How to Review

 
Reviewer Resources

How to Write a Review

Resonance relies on the insight and care of its reviewers. We value respectful, rigorous, and constructive feedback that supports authors and editors alike.

1

Confidentiality

  • The manuscript is a privileged document. Do not share or discuss its content.
  • Do not use any ideas, data, or arguments from the manuscript prior to publication.
2

Initial Reading

Before writing, read the full manuscript carefully.

  • Understand its scope, argument, and contribution.
  • Take notes on strengths, weaknesses, and areas requiring clarification.
3

Structure Your Review

A. Summary of Manuscript Briefly restate the main argument. Demonstrate that you understand the work.
B. Major Comments Address critical issues (originality, methodology, theory). Suggest and justify revisions.
C. Minor Comments Note specific issues like unclear sentences, missing references, or formatting.
D. Final Recommendation
Accept Minor Revisions Major Revisions Reject
4

Tone and Style

  • Be respectful, constructive, and professional.
  • Avoid dismissive or personal language.
  • Frame critiques in terms of improvement, not judgment.
5

Submitting Your Review

  • Use the journal’s online review form or upload a structured report.
  • Indicate your recommendation clearly.
  • You may also submit confidential comments intended only for the editors.
We sincerely appreciate your time and expertise. Your thoughtful review strengthens our process and contributes to the global conversation on music studies.